Subscribe
A changing political landscape of Europe where traditional alliances are being redefined to address new realities.
On November 27, a pivotal moment unfolded in the European Parliament as members cast their votes on the new European Commission headed by Ursula von der Leyen, a prominent figure from the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the European People’s Party (PPE). This vote not only marked an important milestone for the Commission itself, but it also signified a turning point for the future trajectory of the European Union. The proceedings showcased the intricate and often contentious landscape of European politics, highlighting the evolving alliances and rivalries that characterize the Union.
The voting results revealed a narrow approval, with 370 representatives endorsing Von der Leyen’s proposed team of commissioners, while 282 cast their votes against, and 36 chose to abstain. This razor-thin margin of support stands in stark contrast to the overwhelming 401 votes she garnered during her initial nomination in 2019, serving as a testament to the increasing fragmentation and polarization that has become commonplace in the European Parliament. Although the Commission secured the necessary 361 votes for its mandate, this division reflects the underlying tensions and complexities that are significantly shaping the political dynamics across Europe today.
.
Collaboration and Tensions in the Formation of the Commission
The formation of the von der Leyen II Commission showcased the complex and delicate balancing act needed to harmonize the diverse political factions within a deeply fragmented European Parliament. At the heart of this intricate process was a strategic collaboration between the European People’s Party (EPP) and the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR). This alliance not only underscored the necessity of compromise in achieving a cohesive governmental body but also illuminated the increasing influence and significance of conservative and center-right forces in the landscape of European politics. Their partnership symbolized a shift towards a more united front among these groups, as they navigated the challenges of governance in an era marked by ideological divisions and shifting public sentiments.
The Role of the EPP and ECR
The EPP, as the largest political group in the European Parliament, played a pivotal role in securing von der Leyen’s reappointment. However, it was the cooperation with the ECR—a smaller but increasingly influential group—that proved decisive. This collaboration is emblematic of the broader political realignment underway in Europe, where traditional center-right forces are increasingly finding common ground with conservative and nationalist movements.
Fratelli d’Italia (FdI), the prominent Italian party within the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), has demonstrated its increasing clout in the ongoing negotiations. The party’s leader, Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, has underscored her commitment to a pragmatic and strategic approach. She openly supports the initiatives of President Ursula von der Leyen’s Commission, but not without seeking substantial concessions in return. A pivotal outcome of these negotiations was the appointment of Raffaele Fitto as Executive Vice President of the European Commission, where he is entrusted with essential responsibilities for Cohesion and Reforms. This significant appointment not only highlights Meloni’s ambition to place Italy at the forefront of EU decision-making but also reflects her determination to promote a conservative agenda, thereby reinforcing Italy’s leadership role on the European stage.
Raffaele Fitto’s Appointment: A Conservative Victory
The appointment of Raffaele Fitto, a prominent figure in Fratelli d’Italia and the ECR, represents a breakthrough for conservative forces within the EU’s executive body. Fitto’s portfolio, which includes crucial areas like the management of EU cohesion funds and structural reforms, places him at the heart of decision-making on issues critical to the Union’s future. His role is also a testament to the increasing willingness of mainstream parties like the EPP to accommodate conservative voices in the interest of political stability.
This appointment, celebrated by the Meloni government as a “victory for all Italians,” is significant not only for Italy but also for the broader conservative movement in Europe. Fitto’s presence in the Commission is expected to influence key debates, particularly on issues such as national sovereignty, migration policy, and economic governance. His role will likely serve as a platform to advocate for a more restrained EU that respects the subsidiarity principle and empowers member states.
Shifting Dynamics in European Politics
The establishment of the von der Leyen II Commission serves as a significant marker of a larger trend taking root in European politics: the increasing prominence of conservative and nationalist parties within the European Union. This notable shift can be attributed to a confluence of factors. Many citizens are growing disillusioned with the traditional political elite, prompting a desire for change. Additionally, rising apprehensions surrounding immigration and national security are influencing public sentiment. Furthermore, there is a pronounced demand for a restoration of national sovereignty, as many people advocate for greater control over their homeland’s affairs. These dynamics together illustrate a pivotal moment in the evolution of the political landscape in Europe.
The EPP-ECR Alliance: Pragmatism or Ideological Convergence?
While the EPP and ECR have traditionally occupied distinct political spaces—one representing the mainstream center-right and the other championing conservative and more patriotic values—their collaboration in supporting the von der Leyen Commission reflects a pragmatic recognition of shared interests. Both groups see the need to counterbalance the influence of the left-leaning Socialists and Democrats (S&D) and the increasingly vocal Greens in shaping the EU’s agenda.
However, this alliance is not without its challenges. The ECR’s vision of a Europe based on strong nation-states and limited federalism contrasts with the EPP’s more integrationist approach. Balancing these differences while advancing a cohesive agenda will be a key test for this partnership in the years to come.
Challenges Ahead for the Von der Leyen Commission
The von der Leyen II Commission confronts a formidable set of challenges that encompass a wide spectrum of issues, from grappling with profound economic and social crises to tackling the urgent threat of climate change. Additionally, the Commission must deftly navigate an increasingly unpredictable geopolitical landscape where tensions are high. The noticeable divisions reflected in the recent approval vote highlight the difficulty ahead; it will require significant effort and strategic engagement for the Commission to foster cooperation and unity among a fragmented Parliament that is currently at odds with itself.
The Push for Reform
One of the most pressing issues is the need for structural reforms within the EU. The shift toward more conservative policies, driven in part by the ECR’s growing influence, is likely to focus on revisiting the EU’s decision-making processes. There is increasing support for moving away from unanimity requirements in key areas, which have often led to gridlock, toward a system that allows for faster and more efficient decision-making.
Polarization and the Future of the EU
The polarization evident in the European Parliament raises questions about the Union’s ability to respond effectively to the challenges of the 21st century. The growing influence of conservative parties like Fratelli d’Italia reflects a broader trend across member states, where voters are increasingly turning to parties that promise to defend national sovereignty and address concerns over immigration and cultural identity.
Conclusion: A Conservative Inflection Point?
The approval of the von der Leyen II Commission marks a pivotal moment in European politics. The collaboration between the EPP and ECR, exemplified by the appointment of Raffaele Fitto, signals a shift toward a more conservative and pragmatic approach to governance within the EU. This development reflects the changing political landscape of Europe, where traditional alliances are being redefined to address new realities.
As the von der Leyen Commission begins its mandate, it faces the dual challenge of navigating an increasingly polarized Parliament while delivering on its ambitious agenda. The role of conservative forces within this framework will be critical in shaping the Union’s future, offering an alternative vision that prioritizes national sovereignty, security, and economic resilience. Whether this vision will ultimately strengthen or divide the EU remains to be seen.