Subscribe
The Leaders of France and Germany Face Economic and Political Challenges
Over the past several decades, France and Germany have functioned as the twin pillars of the European Union, serving not only as economic powerhouses but also as key political players essential for fostering European integration. Germany recognized as the EU’s leading economic and demographic force, has wielded significant influence over the formulation and implementation of European policies. Its robust industrial capacity and fiscal strength enable it to play a central role in addressing various challenges facing the Union, from managing economic growth to coordinating responses to crises.
Conversely, France has historically been instrumental in defining the EU’s identity and political framework. With a rich legacy of advocating for a strong, unified Europe, France has frequently championed initiatives aimed at deepening integration and enhancing cooperation among member states. This dual leadership has been vital in navigating the complexities of regional governance and in promoting shared values and objectives within the Union.
However, in recent years, both nations have found themselves wrestling with significant internal challenges that pose serious risks not only to their stability but also to the overall cohesion of the European Union. France has faced mounting social unrest driven by economic disparities and political dissatisfaction, while Germany has grappled with the repercussions of demographic shifts and the rise of populist movements that threaten its traditionally stable political landscape. These crises have the potential to undermine their respective roles within the EU, raising concerns about the future direction of European integration and the unity of its member states.
France’s political crisis accelerated significantly with the collapse of Prime Minister Michel Barnier’s government (LR, EPP), which fell after just three months in office. Barnier, a Republican, had replaced Macron’s ally Gabriel Attal (Renaissance, RE) following the latter’s resignation in the wake of disappointing legislative election results last July. The no-confidence motion against Barnier was backed by the left-wing New Popular Front (NFP, S&D + GUE/NGL) and the far-right National Rally (RN, PfE) and was triggered by a controversial €60 billion budget law. The proposed budget included new taxes and cuts to public services, including healthcare, sparking widespread public discontent. President Emmanuel Macron (Renaissance, RE) has stated that he will not resign and has already appointed a new prime minister—his third in 2024—to lead a “government of general interest.” Yet, despite the experience of François Bayrou (MoDem, RE) at the helm, France finds itself mired in political instability.
Barnier’s attempt to establish a stable government failed rapidly. His administration struggled to build political consensus and faced mounting pressure from extremist parties demanding his resignation. With the public deficit at 6.2% of GDP and one of the highest spreads in Europe, the new government faces daunting challenges to stabilize the French economy. It must draft a fiscal plan involving both spending cuts and tax increases, but political instability makes implementing such measures highly complex. Another pressing issue is pension reform, which is essential for addressing the aging population and ensuring long-term financial sustainability.
However, pension reform has historically been deeply unpopular and is likely to encounter strong political and social resistance. Jean-Luc Mélenchon (LFI, GUE/NGL), a vocal critic of such reforms in the past, now finds himself in the awkward position of tempering his opposition to avoid bolstering Marine Le Pen (RN, PfE). The situation is further complicated by the absence of a clear parliamentary majority. Currently, only 22% of the French public expresses satisfaction with Macron’s presidency. While Macron has vowed to govern “until the last second,” his ability to do so is undermined by growing public discontent and the nation’s economic struggles. The prospect of a Mélenchon–Le Pen runoff in the 2027 presidential elections looms large, a scenario that would be unpalatable to centrist forces, from Macron’s allies to the Republicans. Even the so-called “republican barrier” designed to prevent the far-right from winning the presidency may not hold.
Germany, meanwhile, faces a similarly precarious political situation. The governing coalition between the Social Democrats (SPD, S&D), the Greens (Grünen, Greens/EFA), and the Free Democrats (FDP, RE) has fractured. This crisis stems directly from the dismissal of the Minister for Finance Christian Lindner (FDP, RE) over disagreements on the federal budget and Ukraine aid funding. Chancellor Olaf Scholz (SPD, S&D) has announced snap elections for February 23, 2025, after losing a confidence vote in the Bundestag. Scholz’s fall marks a critical juncture for Germany, whose government is now limited to managing current affairs until the elections.
Internal tensions within the coalition have made it difficult to reach agreements on crucial national issues, as Germany plunges into a deep recession. The country’s automotive industry—a sector employing nearly a third of the workforce—faces sustained contraction, further exacerbating economic woes. Political fragmentation threatens Germany’s ability to lead the EU through current financial challenges. Despite these difficulties, the government forecasts a recovery in 2025, with a projected growth of 1.1%. Experts believe the recovery will be driven by increased private consumption and stabilized inflation.
Economy Minister Robert Habeck (Grünen, Greens/EFA) has emphasized the importance of implementing a structural reform package comprising 49 measures aimed at stimulating growth and addressing long-term economic challenges. However, the success of these reforms hinges on political support and governmental stability—both of which are in question. Moreover, the post-election landscape after February 2025 remains uncertain. The opposition Christian Democratic Union (CDU, EPP), currently led by Friedrich Merz, is favored in the polls. Merz’s CDU is advocating tougher policies on immigration and promising increased defense and security spending. Migration policies are poised to become a central electoral issue, with the CDU proposing stricter measures than those of the outgoing government.
Polls estimate the CDU, in coalition with its Bavarian sister party (CSU, EPP), at 30–33% support, giving the center-right alliance a commanding lead over both the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD, ESN) and the left-wing parties. With these numbers, the moderate center-right coalition could govern without additional allies—a rare scenario in recent German history. However, it is vital to address discontent in eastern Germany, where the AfD enjoys significant support. Failure to do so risks strengthening a party still too controversial to lead a nation of Germany’s stature.
The political crises in France and Germany carry significant implications for the European Union. With German elections scheduled for February 23, 2025, and potential early elections in France in June of the same year, the EU stands at a critical crossroads. Internal instability could hinder efforts to tackle growing economic deficits and improve the Union’s competitiveness. Moreover, political uncertainty might fuel the rise of extremist parties in both countries, further complicating Europe’s political landscape. These challenges are particularly acute as Europe faces external pressures, such as the geopolitical challenges posed by newly re-elected U.S. President Donald Trump (GOP, ECR-aligned) and the ongoing need to defend NATO and counterbalance China’s global influence.
In this context, it will be essential to closely monitor the political developments unfolding over the coming months, as they will significantly influence not only the internal stability of France and Germany but also the broader governance framework of the European Union. The situation is particularly precarious, given the difficulties encountered during the formation of Ursula von der Leyen’s second Commission from the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the European People’s Party (EPP). This process faced considerable challenges in securing a cohesive parliamentary majority, indicating underlying tensions within the EU’s political landscape.
Notably, the involvement of Fratelli d’Italia, a right-wing political party, along with the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), played a crucial role in stabilizing the Commission during this tumultuous period for Europe. Their support was instrumental in navigating the complexities of coalition-building, highlighting the delicate balance of power and the shifting alliances that characterize EU politics. As these dynamics evolve, watching for changes in the political climate will be vital for assessing the future trajectory of both foundational EU policies and the overall cohesion of the Union itself.